If your current mattress is waaay too soft and ruining your beauty rest but an upgrade just isn’t in the cards right now, a firm mattress topper is a great alternative. The right topper can quickly revive a limp, lifeless, too-soft mattress at a fraction of the price of a brand-spanking-new one. But where do you start?
We dove into what makes a fab firm mattress topper and picked out 10 stellar models for you to consider.
10 best firm mattress toppers
How we made our top picks
When researching our fave firm mattress toppers, we set the following standards for quality:
Pricing guide
These price ranges are based on queen-size topper pricing.
Best firm mattress toppers
Let’s firm up this sleeping situation.
Best overall firm mattress topper
Brooklyn Bedding Organic Cotton Talalay Latex Topper
Our top pick is the Brooklyn Bedding Organic Cotton Talalay Latex Topper because, besides being organic (❤️), it’s also made of premium Talalay latex — which comes from rubber trees!
The 3-inch-deep mattress topper’s organic cotton cover is both comfy and hypoallergenic.
Reviewers call the topper bouncy and well-made. One person notes that you’ll want to air it out for a few days because it does have a pungent odor.
Best rated firm mattress topper
Plushbeds Natural Latex Topper
This comfy topper has certifications up the wazoo. And with more than 900 happy customers, you can be sure this highly rated latex topper is a great buy.
Choose between two thickness options (2 and 3 inches) and a variety of firmness levels, including medium-firm and extra-firm.
Customers say the extra-firm option is a good choice if you want to upgrade the firmness level of your mattress. One person also notes that the extra-firm topper met their expectations of firmness. Another reviewer even says it felt almost too firm at first.
Best firm mattress topper for sleepers with higher body weight
Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Topper Supreme
This ultra-cushy topper from Tempur-Pedic is the perfect option for folks in larger bodies, thanks to its 3-inch-thick design and proprietary foam. (FYI: Firmness-wise, it’s more on the medium-firm than the extra-firm side.)
The brand claims their foam is the bee’s knees and will last way longer than others. They’re so convinced about its durability that they back it with a 10-year warranty.
What do reviewers have to say? One customer says they bought the topper to add to a not-firm-enough mattress that caused sciatica flare-ups. The verdict? They’ve had a great night’s sleep ever since adding the topper to the mix.
Best budget firm mattress topper
Sealy Essentials Mattress Topper
Our budget-friendly pick is the Sealy Essentials Topper, which features gel-infused memory foam that prevents overheating and delivers pressure relief.
The 3-inch-thick topper (also avail in 2-inch thickness) is CertiPUR-US certified and comes with a 1-year limited warranty.
Reviewers seem happy with the topper — some even say it helps them “sleep like a baby.” The biggest downside? You’ll need to buy a cover for it.
Best organic firm mattress topper
Avocado Organic Latex Mattress Topper
Organic and sustainable? Yes, please!
All of Avocado’s line includes non-toxic, eco-friendly products, and this topper is no exception.
It’s made from organic latex and a cotton cover. While the main model has a wool layer for added breathability, you may also opt for the vegan version. And you can choose from plush and firm options.
There are currently more than 2,200 reviews of this topper on the website, and it’s averaging a 4.6 out of 5 rating, with raves about overall comfort.
Best firm mattress topper for back pain
Lift by Amerisleep Mattress Topper
If your current mattress makes your back pain worse but the idea of leveling up will cause pain in your wallet, this pressure-relieving topper is a solid add-on.
The support firmness option is ideal if you’re looking to firm up your bed. A grippy back keeps the topper from slipping and sliding, and the topper has a soft, removable cover that’s easy to wash.
One customer who opted for the support option says the topper’s firmness is just right. But a few peeps complain that it’s a little too firm.
Remember that firmness can vary, depending on your weight — and your preference plays a part in whether you’ll like a particular topper.
Best firm mattress topper for couples
ViscoSoft Select High-Density Mattress Topper
This super-durable 3-inch topper will keep both you and your sleeping partner comfy and supported, thanks to high density foam and adjustable straps.
Even if you and your partner toss and turn, the straps and slip-resistant mesh keep the topper in place all night long. It also comes in a gentle lavender option for added sleepytime vibes. Plus, the cover is removable and easy to wash.
Reviewers love that the topper doesn’t sleep hot and provides lotsa support. BUT that high density design means it’s a hefty topper. The king-size option weighs nearly 40 pounds. (Time to start weightlifting!)
Who does a firm mattress topper make sense for?
A firm topper is an excellent choice if you:
Pros and cons of firm mattress toppers
Here’s a quick breakdown of some high level perks and drawbacks of owning a firm mattress topper:
Frequent questions from firm mattress topper newbies
We read your mind and figured you might have more questions. So here’s a roundup of the most frequently asked ones and our crack at clearing them up.
Can a firm mattress topper make my mattress firmer?
Uh, no. A firm topper can’t magically fix your mattress. Adding a firm layer on top still means you have a soft layer underneath, and eventually you’ll need to replace your mattress if it sags or dips too much.
(Expect most mattresses to last about 10 years, BTW.)
How do I know if my firm mattress topper is too firm?
If you regularly wake up with aches and pains in spots like your hips and shoulders, your sleep surface might be too hard.
A topper or mattress that’s too firm can create pressure points on your body, potentially making any existing joint pain worse. Your morning discomfort may also mean your mattress is on its way out.
What should I do if my partner prefers a softer sleeping surface?
This is the subject of many nightly feuds between couples. We suggest using a smaller mattress pad just for your side of the bed. And if your partner still thinks your bed is too firm, they can opt for a softer topper on theirs.
Should I put a firm mattress topper on a mattress that’s 10+ years old?
It can help temporarily, but it won’t solve the problems of an ancient mattress — sagging, lumps, etc.
What’s the difference between a mattress pad and a mattress topper?
A mattress pad is typically thinner and doesn’t usually provide support. Most people add these thin pads for extra softness, not firmness.
Toppers are thicker and, whether they’re firm or soft, can extend the life of your mattress.
What to consider when choosing your firm mattress topper
Ask yourself the following when shopping for a firm mattress topper:
The bottom line
If you’re sick of sleeping on a too-soft mattress, a firm mattress topper (especially one of our recs) might be just what you need to transform your Zzz’s and enjoy a night of sweet dreams. 😴
